The Cleveland Guardians kicked off the season with a strong start, showing promise and energy, but their momentum has significantly waned as the year progressed. June was particularly rough, with the team posting a disappointing 9-16 record, marking one of the most lackluster offensive performances in the franchise’s history. This downward spiral has positioned the Guardians as likely sellers at the upcoming trade deadline, prompting discussions about which players should remain with the team and which could be moved to reshape the roster for the future.
Analyst Bruce Drennan recently weighed in on this topic, offering his perspective on the players he believes the Guardians should hold onto and those who could be traded. Drennan was clear in his stance, emphasizing that only two players should be considered untouchable: Jose Ramirez and Steven Kwan. He went as far as to suggest that even Emmanuel Clase, the team’s closer, could be on the trading block. “If we’re looking to sell, I said last week that the only players I’d keep off the table are Jose and Kwan. I’m not interested in trading Kwan, but I would consider moving Clase,” Drennan stated, sparking conversation about the team’s potential direction.
While Drennan’s take might seem bold or even controversial to some fans, his reasoning carries weight when examined closely. Steven Kwan, despite experiencing a dip in form after an electrifying start to the season, remains one of the Guardians’ standout performers. At 27 years old, Kwan is not only a key contributor on the field but also a vital presence in the clubhouse, providing leadership and stability. His age and skill set make him a cornerstone for the team’s future, and trading him, no matter how attractive an offer might be, would likely be shortsighted given his long-term value to the organization.
Emmanuel Clase, however, presents a different case. Once regarded as the premier closer in Major League Baseball, Clase has shown signs of regression this season. While he remains a valuable asset, his performance has not matched the dominance he displayed in previous years. Drennan’s suggestion to trade Clase stems from a strategic perspective: moving him now, while his trade value is still relatively high, could yield a significant return in prospects or players who could bolster the Guardians’ roster for years to come. Waiting too long risks diminishing Clase’s value further if his performance continues to trend downward. This approach reflects a pragmatic mindset, prioritizing the team’s long-term competitiveness over holding onto a player whose peak may have already passed.
The Guardians’ struggles in June have forced the organization to confront tough decisions as the trade deadline approaches. Drennan’s analysis underscores the importance of retaining core players like Ramirez and Kwan, who represent the heart of the team, while being open to moving others, like Clase, to maximize the team’s future potential. As the deadline nears, the Guardians’ front office will need to weigh these options carefully, balancing immediate needs with the goal of building a sustainable contender.
