The New York Giants are continuing to put in the work ahead of the 2025 NFL Draft, recently hosting Colorado quarterback Shedeur Sanders for a private workout on Thursday. While it comes as no shock that the Giants are thoroughly evaluating their options with the No. 3 overall pick, the timing of this meeting is notable, as reports suggest Sanders’ draft stock has begun to slide considerably in recent weeks.
Although Sanders turned in an impressive statistical season in 2024, doubts are starting to surface about whether his production truly reflects his long-term potential at the NFL level.
A Sharp Passer with Lingering Concerns
Last season, Sanders was one of the most precise passers in college football. He completed an impressive 73.4% of his throws, with an adjusted completion percentage of 81.8%. His final tally of 4,133 passing yards, 37 touchdowns, and just 10 interceptions makes for a stat line typically associated with a top-five draft pick.
However, once scouts take a closer look at the tape, some of the concerns around Sanders become more apparent. His arm strength is average by NFL standards; deep throws tend to lose velocity, and his passes to the sidelines often lack the tight zip professional teams desire. Additionally, Sanders’ athleticism isn’t on par with many of today’s dual-threat quarterbacks. He has a tendency to drift in the pocket and lacks the mobility that has become highly valued in many modern offensive systems. These limitations have contributed to a cooling of interest from several quarterback-needy teams.
Giants Expected to Look Elsewhere at No. 3
Despite giving Sanders an up-close evaluation, the prevailing sense around the league is that New York is leaning in a different direction with their top pick. Reports suggest the Giants are prioritizing the best available talent over reaching for a quarterback. Potential targets include Travis Hunter, the versatile star from Colorado capable of contributing on both sides of the ball, or Penn State edge rusher Abdul Carter, both of whom are considered immediate impact players.
With veteran signal-callers Russell Wilson and Jameis Winston already on the roster, there’s less urgency for the Giants to gamble on a developmental quarterback who may not see the field in 2025.
A Possible Draft Night Slide?
Fueling speculation, ESPN insider Adam Schefter recently hinted that Sanders could experience a steep fall on draft night. “It certainly feels like his range is from three to 21,” Schefter noted, adding that he’s doubtful Sanders gets selected at No. 9.
Such uncertainty is unusual for a quarterback who spent much of the college season projected inside the top-10. Yet, in today’s NFL, traits often outweigh stats, and Sanders’ perceived ceiling may not excite enough teams near the top of the draft board.
While draft week surprises are always possible, it appears Sanders’ stock is trending downward. Could he fall far enough for the Giants to consider a trade back into the first round? That remains a storyline to monitor as the draft approaches next week.
