The Milwaukee Brewers have had a relatively quiet offseason so far, apart from losing their star shortstop, Willy Adames, who signed with the San Francisco Giants in free agency. As the Brewers aim to clinch the National League Central title for the third consecutive season in 2025, one pressing question looms: who will fill the void left by Adames?
Among the potential solutions is a trade with the New York Mets for third baseman Brett Baty. David Gasper of Reviewing the Brew recently explored this possibility, arguing that Baty could be a key piece to strengthen Milwaukee’s infield.
Baty, a former top prospect, has struggled to find consistent success in the majors, posting a career slash line of .215/.282/.325 with 15 home runs and an OPS+ of 70 across 500 MLB at-bats. However, his minor league numbers suggest untapped potential that could flourish with a change of scenery. Gasper noted that Baty’s future with the Mets remains uncertain, especially with Mark Vientos establishing himself as New York’s everyday third baseman. The situation could become clearer once the Mets decide on Pete Alonso’s future. If Alonso re-signs, Vientos could stay at third base, leaving Baty without a long-term role.
Milwaukee’s front office, led by David Stearns, could seize this opportunity to acquire Baty at a relatively low cost, given his diminished trade value. Despite his struggles, Baty’s five remaining seasons of team control align perfectly with the Brewers’ focus on long-term roster stability. At just 25 years old, he would bring power to the hot corner while fitting into the Brewers’ youthful core.
If Milwaukee were to land Baty, the next logical move would be shifting Joey Ortiz, the current third baseman, to shortstop. Ortiz, who has shown promise, could fill the vacancy left by Adames. This adjustment would allow Baty to become an everyday player at third base, where he could focus on unlocking his offensive potential.
Gasper believes the Brewers should act quickly if Alonso re-signs with the Mets, effectively sealing Baty’s fate as a trade candidate. “While long-term control over a former highly touted prospect usually comes at a high cost, Baty’s value is at a low point, and if the Brewers believe they can unlock his offensive potential, they could make a swing for him,” Gasper wrote.
For Baty, Milwaukee could represent the fresh start he needs. Last season, he posted a modest .229 batting average with four home runs, 16 RBIs, and a .306 on-base percentage in limited action. However, his raw talent suggests he could thrive in a new environment where he’s given regular playing time.
If the Brewers are serious about maintaining their dominance in the NL Central, trading for Brett Baty could be a calculated risk worth taking.
