The St. Louis Cardinals are actively exploring trade options for third baseman Nolan Arenado, looking for a team willing to take on his remaining $52 million contract. As other teams begin to bolster their rosters, it has become increasingly challenging to find a suitable trade partner. However, one potential team that could be an option for the Cardinals is the Philadelphia Phillies.
Although reports have circulated about the Phillies discussing Alec Bohm with other teams, they have not shown any indication of actively shopping him. Despite this, Kerry Miller of Bleacher Report has suggested a possible trade scenario involving the two third basemen, Arenado and Bohm. According to Miller, one of Arenado’s preferred destinations listed was the Phillies, which could make this deal intriguing for both sides.
For the deal to make sense, Miller proposes a three-team trade. In this scenario, the Cardinals would send Arenado to the Phillies, who would then ship Alec Bohm to the Seattle Mariners. In return, the Mariners would send shortstop Colt Emerson—currently ranked as the 35th overall prospect by Joel Reuter—back to St. Louis. This trade could benefit all the teams involved.
The Phillies would receive an upgrade at third base with Arenado, strengthening their lineup for a deeper playoff run. The Cardinals would clear Arenado’s hefty contract from their books, setting the stage for a potential rebuild. Meanwhile, the Mariners would gain a valuable power hitter in Bohm, boosting their offensive capabilities for the upcoming season.
This trade scenario would likely mark the beginning of a rebuilding phase for the Cardinals. However, they would still retain a solid third baseman in Bohm, whom they could quickly look to build around. A trade like this would make sense for each of the teams involved, addressing their respective needs while also providing financial relief for the Cardinals as they move forward in their rebuilding process.
If this proposed trade were to come to fruition, it could reshape the fortunes of all three teams and bring about a significant shift in the balance of the league. The Phillies, bolstered by a proven star like Arenado, would position themselves as a stronger contender in the National League. The Mariners would have an exciting new addition to their offense in Bohm, while the Cardinals could begin to focus on the future.
