Eagles to Land Four-Time All-Pro as C.J. Gardner-Johnson’s Replacement

The Philadelphia Eagles are set to have a significantly different roster in 2025 compared to the previous season due to key departures via free agency and trades. One of the most notable moves was the trade of safety C.J. Gardner-Johnson to the Houston Texans. In exchange, the Eagles received offensive lineman Kenyon Green and a 2025 fifth-round pick, while also sending a 2026 sixth-round pick to Houston. Losing Gardner-Johnson, who played a crucial role in Philadelphia’s defense by starting 16 regular-season games and all of their playoff matchups, leaves a major void in the secondary.

CBS Sports analyst Cody Benjamin believes the Eagles could address this issue by signing veteran safety Justin Simmons. Despite being 31 years old, Simmons remains a valuable defensive presence, particularly due to his experience under Vic Fangio’s defensive system from their time together with the Denver Broncos. Benjamin noted that Simmons has already expressed interest in joining the Eagles, making this a realistic option for Philadelphia’s offseason plans.

Justin Simmons landing spots: Safety says Eagles, Commanders 'high on the  list' in 2025 NFL free agency - CBSSports.com
Justin Simmons landing spots

Simmons spent the 2024 season with the Atlanta Falcons, where he continued to perform at a high level. In coverage, he was targeted 37 times, allowing 22 receptions for 229 yards and three touchdowns, while recording a passer rating of 81.9 when thrown against. He also contributed two interceptions and seven pass deflections, showing that he can still make an impact in the secondary.

For comparison, Gardner-Johnson had a strong season but posted slightly different numbers. He recorded six interceptions and 12 pass deflections, while allowing 23 receptions for 312 yards and eight touchdowns on 37 targets. His passer rating allowed was 89, making Simmons’ statistics fairly comparable.

Financially, signing Simmons wouldn’t require a significant long-term investment. According to Spotrac, his projected market value is around $5.8 million annually, making him an affordable option for the Eagles. Given his experience, ability to read the field, and proven production, Simmons could be an ideal replacement for Gardner-Johnson without causing financial strain.

Ultimately, with the Eagles looking to retool their defense, adding a reliable veteran like Simmons could help stabilize the secondary. His familiarity with Fangio’s system and continued productivity suggest he could step in and contribute immediately, filling the void left by Gardner-Johnson. As the Eagles aim to stay competitive in the NFC, making a smart, cost-effective move like this could be crucial to maintaining a strong defensive unit.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *