The Milwaukee Brewers face a significant challenge heading into the 2025 MLB season: finding a new closer after trading away Devin Williams, their two-time Trevor Hoffman Reliever of the Year. Williams’ departure leaves a glaring hole in the bullpen, but it’s a situation that manager Pat Murphy is familiar with. Last season, Murphy navigated a similar scenario when Williams missed time due to stress fractures in his back. As the Brewers assess their options for the closer role, an unexpected candidate has emerged, sparking intrigue among fans and analysts alike.
Returning Closers in 2025
Several players who recorded saves for the Brewers last season are set to return, offering potential solutions to the closer conundrum. Trevor Megill appears to be the early favorite, having led the team with 21 saves in 2024. Other returning pitchers include Joel Payamps (6 saves), Abner Uribe (3 saves), Elvis Peguero (2 saves), and Jared Koenig (1 save). Each brings unique strengths to the table, giving the Brewers a range of choices for late-game situations.
A Surprising Contender
MLB.com writer Adam McCalvy recently added an unexpected name to the conversation: Aaron Ashby. While Ashby’s career has been marked by flashes of brilliance, including a few “mini-breakouts,” his recent success out of the bullpen has made him a dark horse candidate for the closer role. Ashby signed a five-year, $20.5 million extension with the Brewers in 2022 and has since shown significant growth. McCalvy speculates that although the team may initially use Ashby as a starter, his performance in relief could make him a viable closer if the need arises.
Ashby’s Bullpen Success in 2024
Last season, Ashby made 12 relief appearances, pitching 19.2 innings with a stellar 1.37 ERA. His improved velocity as a reliever was evident, and his strikeout-to-walk ratio was particularly impressive, striking out 28 batters while issuing just three walks. These numbers highlight his potential as a dominant bullpen arm, especially if he continues to regain confidence and form after recovering from major shoulder surgery.
Looking Ahead
As the Brewers prepare for the 2025 season, Aaron Ashby’s role remains uncertain. Will he be stretched out as a starter, or will his success in relief earn him a permanent spot in the bullpen? Given his ability to return to pre-injury velocity and produce positive results, Ashby’s potential as a closer is an exciting prospect for the team and fans alike.
The Brewers’ decision on who will step into the closer role will be a critical factor in their success this season. Whether it’s Megill, Ashby, or another contender, the team has intriguing options to explore as they aim to remain competitive in the National League.
